Also known as
Janghwa, Hongryeon
Specifics
South Korea [2003] - 115m
Genre
Horror, Mystery
Directed by
Jee-woon Kim
More info on
rating
3.5*/5.0*
A Tale of Two Sisters poster

Watches

February 27, 2004

4.0*/5.0*

June 15, 2022

3.5*/5.0*

Gone are the days of the Asian suspense hype. A film like A Tale of Two Sisters used to be quite grand and impressive, two decades later the base quality is still there, it's just not quite as special anymore. I still had fun revisiting this film, but I had a hard time recognizing the personal favorite I once knew.

Su-mi and her sister Su-yeon return to live with their father and stepmother. They have a pretty bad relationship with her, their father tries to distance himself from the feud. The situation slowly escalates, but then hints are dropped that the mental stability of some of the family members may not be as stable as first suggested.

The stylish setting, the deliberate pacing and the fine performance are timeless qualities, the simple twist and the everlasting finale (which tries way too hard to explain things) drag the film down. Even worse, the scares and tension aren't quite as effective as they used to be. Might be more fun if it's your first time watching, doesn't really hold up on multiple viewings.

More by the director