films seen
average score
Alive and kicking
more info

Worthy but flawed


1999 / 88m - USA
Animation, Adventure
Tarzan poster

Plain forgettable


2007 / 107m - USA
Fantasy, Adventure
Enchanted poster

102 Dalmatians

2000 / 100m - USA
102 Dalmatians poster

The first live action adaptation was surprisingly solid. It was a polished and cute little film that charmed its way from start to finish. Kevin Lima tries to replicate that success in this sequel, but he's clearly a worse director than Herek. The result feels derivative and sloppy, which is a real shame.

Read all

For one, it feels a lot less British. The leads are less agreeable, Depardieu is somewhat of a miscast (one completely over the top villain was more than plenty) and the cozy, warm atmosphere seems to be replaced by a harsher American vibe. That's not really what I was hoping to see here.

At least the sets are still pretty nice looking, but that's about the only positive thing to say (well, apart from the decent pacing maybe). It's just not as fun and quirky the second time around. Worse cast, worse plot, worse comedy. It's worse in just about every way and I blame Lima's input.

Irritation overload

A Goofy Movie

1995 / 78m - USA
Animation, Comedy
A Goofy Movie poster